Skip to main content

Sergio Soraci, thoughts on climbing bans in Italy

Crag closures by Italian local authorities or by the rightful owners, and social role of the private property provided by the Italian Constitution. We are pleased to publish some thoughts of Sergio Soraci, Sicilian climber, and nailer. 

Castelmola
Castelmola, in Sicily, now closed
Sergio Soraci

"Prohibitions and closures are a daily occurence in Italy, and I'm referring to the natural environments and the ones used by man and then abandoned.

The natural areas available for those who love to practice outdoor activities are getting fewer, and I'm not referring to the global pandemic, but to the leading and powerful role played by the private ownership in the country. In these lines, of course, I want to focus on the spaces, the places that now got fruitless, and abandoned by their rughtful owners, and however off-limits to most for the simple reason that they are a private property.

Yet, in Italy there is a legislative assumption providing that property can't be only "private". In particular, the article 42 second paragraph of the Italian constitution even provides for a social use of the private property.   I wanted to make this point because the closure cases of climbing spots located in uncultivated and fruitless lands  are becoming ever more numerous.

Only rarely there are reasonable arrangements between owners and climbers, between State property and goers, between various institutions and passionate about climbing and nailing. Excluding those cases in which there are some unacceptable behaviors, often climbing takes place at abandoned or semi-abandoned places, with suitable rock walls.

Often, the closing notice of a spot arrives after several years of climbing, motivated by environmental issues or simply by an owner assertion. Some is horrified at the thought of restricting the rights of private persons, but the Italian post-fascist law  established limits to the latifundium and to the ancient feuds, and, for various reasons, provided a social use of them; with that sais, I'm realistic, and I realize that in our country the private ownership enjoys absolute inviolability."

Colle dell'Orso, Morgia Quadra
Morgia Quadra, in Colle dell'Orso, closed by the municipality of Frosolone
Carmela Malomo

"I saw pretty good arrangements between climber associations and owners, institutions, public administration, for the achievement of reasonable opening and agreed permissions, not in Italy, but in France, Spain, and United States. Some Italian example will certainly exist, but I'm not aware of them. The positive examples are overshadowed by the numerous, unjustified closures, which, along with numerous and of various kinds bans, are an easy shortcut to keep from being sensible. 

The recent crag closures, like those of Castelmola in Sicily, Colle dell'Orso in Molise, and other in the province of Bergamo and Trieste, should lead us to consider possible solutions to be adopted to prevent this phenomenon."

 

by Sergio Soraci

 

Commenti

Anonymous (not verified)

Ottime le tue considerazioni Sergio, ma da noi credo che gli accordi possibili con i proprietari dei terreni possano essere solo di natura economica. Che si tengano pulite, vaorizzate e con tanta gente che trascorre giornate allegre ad arrampicare, intere aree belle panoramiche ma abbandonate completamente da anni, be' ai loro proprietari non gliene importa molto. Ma se ci fosse un compenso economico...forse ci ripenserebbero. Non so, forse .
Una specie di affitto che si crea con conttibuti volontari. Così sarebbero più motivati a lasciarci fare. Spero tanto che Castelmola possa rinascere, riavere tutto quello che avete costruito. È un posto magnifico!

Mon, 11/09/2020 - 20:19

Leave a comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.